H1 steel vs s30v It can withstand rigorous use without chipping or breaking. S30V is a very good steel, but it bugs me that both lower-carbon (AUS-6, 13C26) at about the same hardness and higher-carbon (ZDP-189, Compare S45VN, S30V, and S35VN knife steels. Gold Member. Soft steels like 420HC tend to offer great toughness. 14C28N vs S30V steel comparison table Hardness. Meanwhile SPY-27 consistently does about 300 feet in the same test. S30V is a good steel and is omnipresent in so many of today's knives, but I'm tired of it. It's basically just iron and carbon, the minimum ingredients to count as a steel. LC200N, on the According to the chemical composition and the HRC of the steel, the CPM S30V Steel has the following features: Edge Retention: With a maximum of 61HRC due to the mixture of H2 vs S30V. In this article, we will compare D2 and S30V in terms of their composition, hardness, toughness, corrosion resistance, edge retention, and ease of sharpening to conclude which one is superior for knives. So, it only makes sense to compare the two. 4116 12C27 14C28N 440A 440B 440C steel 1060 1095 52100 AEB-L ApexUltra blue steel Chef knife Chef Knives CPM 3V CPM 4V CPM 154 CROMOVA Cronidur 30 D2 steel Damascus drop point Elmax FRN G10 grivory H1 H2 LC200N M390 MagnaCut MC66 Micarta n690 pocket knife Rex 45 rex 121 s30v S35VN S45VN S90V SG2 SUS410 Tanto VG 10 Steel people that still want more edge retention will always continue to favor steels that score higher there. It’s like the high-end jack of all trades for knife steel. 73 posts Previous; 1; 2; 3; 4; Next Production of H1 Steel for Knives. They couldn’t be further apart. 575 with S30V, or a difference of about 10%. However, AEB-L’s higher toughness makes it less prone to chipping, especially under heavy use. vilePossum Member Posts: 339 Joined: Thu Feb 05, 2015 10:03 am. S30V has a higher vanadium content, making it tougher but slightly more challenging to sharpen. Discover the differences in performance, durability, and edge retention to choose the best steel for your needs. It is also very resistant to chipping and breaking. Not taking anything away from S30V, it's a very good steel, but CV20 holds a fine edge longer, I personally don't think it chips worse than S30V and I don't notice a difference in sharpening ease. S30V steel, a product of Crucible Industries, is enriched with vanadium. Ease of Sharpening The ease of sharpening refers to how difficult/easy and how long it will take to sharpen a blade to a fine usable edge. lower cost. Both components are so great for the machine. Also, the Endura does not come in S30V. It was not planned. On top of the superior edge retention, S30V steel is easier to sharpen than D2 – not only in the amount of grinding required but also more manageable on the whetstone. It's a great all-rounder and is why so many of the main no-joke knives from the major companies come in it. According to Crucible Industries the maker of these steels, S35VN Steel is actually a variation of S30V steel, while S45VN is a variation of S35VN. S110V: S110V is another super steel with excellent edge retention and corrosion S30V vs 154CM: Best Steel Choice for Your Pocket Knife; The Benefits of Elmax Steel Blades; Detailed DSR-1K6 Steel Review; blue steel Chef knife Chef Knives CPM 3V CPM 4V CPM 154 CROMOVA Cronidur 30 D2 steel Damascus drop point Elmax FRN G10 grivory H1 H2 LC200N M390 MagnaCut MC66 Micarta n690 pocket knife Rex 45 rex 121 s30v CPM S30V steel vs S35VN steel? I have been debating sending in my 2005 Sebenza for a new blade with the S35VN steel. ZDP-189 versus CPM-S30V. The addition of vanadium enhances its hardness and durability. Let’s S30V steel contains 14% of Chromium, which gives it great corrosion resistance, S30V steel does not rust easily. At A GlanceCPM M4, a high-speed tool CPM M4 vs S30V – Complete Comparison CPM S30V vs CTS BD1 steel. You've generated some discussion here and that's good. 1. H1: A product of Myodo Metal, a Japanese manufacturer of steel, this metal is essentially rustproof However, S30V steel is considered to be a higher-end steel with better edge retention and corrosion resistance, making it a better option for prolonged outdoor use. CTS BD1 vs S30v Steel. Much, much better than H1 (not hard to do). The Mo addition was not made to 154CM for corrosion resistance, but the recognition of good corrosion resistance in 1. S30V has a Rockwell hardness (HRC) of 59-61, making it a hard steel that can hold an edge for a long time. This is a powder-metal steel also produced by Crucible. 80%: Increases the edge retention, hardness and tensile strength. First, the same steel can have different hardness depending on how it is heat treated. The H1 steel produced for Spyderco is reported to begin with 7 mm stock and is cold rolled down to the final thickness required [8], to as thick as 3 mm for a Schempp chopper [9], or probably as S30V and CPM-S30V have very similar names, but are they even different? Is there a reason that one has CPM and the other doesn’t? In this article, we will answer all of those questions. It's a pretty good general guideline. However, The BD1 is the cheapest and unless one of the other ones is greatly superior I would lean toward that. 15% C, 16. When comparing CTS BD1N and SPY27 side-by-side, CTS BD1N does have advantages in corrosion resistance and ease of sharpening. 420HC vs S30V Toughness. And. Both of these steels have their reputation for being reliable, strong, holding an edge, and corrosion resistant. It is crafted, or rather engineered, to offer a steadfast performance. Newbies find the steel a bit hard to sharpen in my experience (my friends complain they cant get it sharp). Usually I don't care much about steel types, but the chipping was so bad that stropping the steel for maintenance was no longer an option, so I actually try to avoid S30V. Yes, 52100 steel and S30V steel are great materials for knife blades, but S30V is more expensive. S90V vs. Ok so i was thinking of getting a spyderco ukpk OR a spyderco h1 dragonfly, I like how the ukpk is made in usa :cool: but i also like the virtual Knife Exchange. If you frequently are holding something with one hand and need to open a knife, use it, and then close it without letting go of the other item (mail, pipes,etc), you will absolutely love the axis lock. 5% niobium, S35VN vs S90V Steel Comparison Table Hardness. A very basic low alloy steel like 1095 is still very solid. S30V steels exhibit higher hardness levels compared to 14C28N Steel due to its distinct alloy compositions and microstructure. But if you’re willing to pay more, then you might like the S30V. The toughness of steel is often inversely proportional to the hardness. Exotic Stainless Steel. However, I have no experience with S110 or BD1. 50%: Formation of Read More: S35VN Knife Steel Review. S30V steel contains 14% of Chromium, which gives it great corrosion resistance, S30V steel does not rust easily. However, it is not on the list of easy to sharpen steels. K390 steel has the potential to reach higher hardness levels than S30V steel, according to the data sheets, K390 can reach a hardness of up to 66 HRC while S30V can reach a hardness of 63 HRC. The Mo addition was not made to 154CM for corrosion resistance, but the recognition of good corrosion resistance in 154CM with relatively low Cr in solution was used to develop other steels designed to take advantage of Mo, such as S30V and S110V. In-Depth Look at CPM-S30V However, if you are willing to pay a little extra, S30v steel is the best choice for superior edge retention and corrosion resistance. While it's wear resistance is slightly less than S30V, when the edge is maintained like most of us do, and non abrasive materials are cut, like most of us cut, SPY-27 will have Since the BG42 steel is not readily available, some might be interested in the alternatives they can go for. Spy27 and S30v steel are two of the most cutting-edge steels on the market today. I have an S30V PM2 and like the steel. Yet, there are reasons you may actually want to choose S30V is unquestionably the better steel and the price tags will reflect it. When deciding between d2 tool steel vs s30v steel for your next knife purchase, consider your intended purpose and environment – whether you plan to use your knife indoors or outdoors, whether you need more edge 12c27 steel has a Rockwell hardness of 58-59 HRC. M390, on the other hand, has an HRC of 60-62. Both the Benchmade Bugout S30V and Spyderco Lil Native S30V give me a test result of about 150 feet, every time. Let’s dive deep into the CRUWEAR vs S30V comparison to help you make the best steel choice for your next knife purchase. Final Thoughts on CTS BD1N vs S30V Steel. Although H1 is a rather different steel from LC200N or Vanax, but is it possible that other nitrogen steels(LC200N, Vanax etc) could have the similar characteristics(low springness) as well? S30V is more of a steel nuts steel, most people with S30V can sharpen a knife. This is because of the complexity of a special manufacturing process involved in S30V data sheet notes that while it is much easier to machine than CPM S90V and is comparable to that of D2, note that D2 steel is still harder to sharpen than CTS BD1N steel. LC200N vs H1 Steel Comparison Table Corrosion Resistance. S30V vs. The high carbon levels in its composition make this possible. K390 steel has higher Vanadium content at 9. It has good edge retention, good toughness, good wear resistance, and is pretty stainless. 3. I have some knives in H1 and LC200N but not Vanax yet. So which is best for EDC? I also like the g10 handles that come with the s30v so it may be worth the extra $10-$15 over the BD1 lightweight version. I would generally recommend S30V as the better overall performer for most knife applications. 420HC offers better Toughness than S30V due to the decreased Rockwell hardness, it is thus less brittle than S30V steel. 4110 or X55CrMo14 steel (GEAR PERSONAL) is certainly not going to be your first pick in a knife steel. Features I wrote about this in the article on the development of 154CM, a steel with 14% Cr and 4% Mo. so there’s still compromise required when looking into this blade steel. Both HAP40 and ZDP-189 steel belong to the high carbon steel family. S30V steel is a martensitic stainless steel that is known for its wear resistance and toughness. CPM S30V knife steel was originally developed in collaboration with Spyderco and Chris Reeve Knives in the early 2000s to improve upon existing stainless steels like 154CM. Vanadium is included in both of these steels. CPM 154 steel and S30V steel are both produced using the same process. With this, we can say that H1 is Sharpness: H1 steel is easy to sharpen. S30V is an American steel and the Endura is a Japanese knife. HAP40 steel equivalent HAP40 vs ZDP189. Short Answer: Comparing S30V to CPM-20CV S30V is a more well-rounded steel that is good From my perspective, SPY27 knife steel is an impressive performer that leverages the qualities of its predecessor steel S30V quite well. VG10 steel outperforms H1 in edge retention while H1 shines on toughness, corrosion resistance and is easier to sharpen. 5% Cr, 6% Ni, 1% CTS XHP vs S30V Steel comparison table Hardness. Properties: LC200N: S30V: Sharpness: 9/10: 8/10: Corrosion Resistance: 10/10: 7/10: Edge retention: 8/10: 9/10: Toughness: S30V steel is a stainless steel with a bright, silvery finish. The two SPY27 specimens look relatively similar to S30V, and all three are significantly worse than the 420. This is another seemingly unfair comparison, when you realize that the S30V steel is one of the premium steels around. I was under the impression H2 is merely the same steel as H1 with a new name since having to switch steel producers after the original stopped 420HC vs S30v Steel. Nothing wrong with 440c! It's real nice. I think Spyderco made their AUS8 blades harder than Cold Steel did, so the Voyager is not a perfect example of that steel. 12 posts • Page 1 of 1. They all bring really crucial benefits, and now we’re going to examine why these are so handy. I've said it before, but for me H1 and LC200N take less work to maintain than K390 or S30V. 0 ft-lbs. It is virtually fully waterproof and will not show any signs of rusting even after a week underwater. CPM S30V and CPM Cru-Wear are both air-hardening tool steels that can achieve high Rockwell hardness levels, making them suitable for wear-resistant applications like knives, cutting tools and dies. H1 is perfect for those who work around water or in other damp environments. other CPM steels. However, they are typically heat-treated within the 60-62 HRC range to strike an Cons of S30V Steel. Stainless steel, One of the Marine Approved top recommendations for a knife CPM-S45VN has a slightly higher amount of chromium and niobium than S30V, which can improve its wear resistance and toughness. Qboy Member and that's not a 'hard' use at all. S30V and S90V are just a few of the CPM steels – there are many others. Nitro V Steel vs S30V. Yes, the s30v compares very well with 420hc when it comes to corrosion resistance, though 420hc is a little bit more rust-resistant. Harder steel (as measured in the Rockwell C scale in HRC) maintains an edge longer but is harder to sharpen. However, stainless steel is at risk of corrosion if neglected and exposed to corrosion agents. There’s a reason that S30V is such a popular steel for making knife blades with, and that’s because of this great range of chemical ingredients. Carbon and tool steels (chromium content less than 13%) S30V and SPY27 are two premium stainless steels made by Crucible Industries for use in knives. S30V, properly called CPM S30V, is a hardened powder steel with a unique formulation that promotes the formation and uniform distribution of vanadium carbides which lend this formula its excellent I’m curious for any more experienced steel folk’s take on what the better steel is in a large (6inch Delica zdp; Caly 3. This makes it a relatively mild steel that is easy to sharpen. D2 vs S35VN composition D2 Knife Characteristics. AEB-L vs VG10 CPM 154 and 154 CM are two completely different beasts. It also offers a good balance of everything one might want in a blade steel. When it comes to edge H1 vs. Assisted vs non assisted is not really an issue on modern folders - especially the griptillian. But how do they compare? In this article, we will look at each steel and see how they compare. Have: old S30V Native, HAP40 Endura, ZDP DF2, S110V Manix LW, Cru-wear Para 3, Blade steel; CPM-M4 vs VG-10 vs S30V vs ZDP-189. A super steel that is hailed by some as the ultimate EDC blade steel is the S30V. S30V is a very balanced steel in terms of edge retention, wear resistance, and corrosion resistance. I am somewhat tempted to re-write large chunks of that article here because H1 is steel questions/comments: H1, 440V, s30v. 1095 on the other hand blue steel Chef knife Chef Knives CPM 3V CPM 4V CPM 154 CROMOVA Cronidur 30 D2 steel Damascus drop point Elmax FRN G10 grivory H1 H2 LC200N M390 MagnaCut MC66 Micarta n690 pocket SPY27 steel higher toughness is primarily attributed to its lower overall alloy content and finer carbide structure. The steels show better performances in different edge types. With the short answer out of the way, we can take a closer look at each steel individually, when and why you would want one steel over the other, and how one steel is better than the other. Oct 26, 2009 #3 I wrote about this in the article on the development of 154CM, a steel with 14% Cr and 4% Mo. Finally, the cost of each steel is an essential factor in making a decision. Joined Nov 13, 2015 Messages 2,887. After exposure to corrosive elements that would tarnish even the most stain-resistant steels out there, H1 simply will not rust. Ill try to figure out something for my plain edge h1 vs plain edge lc200n tomorrow and see if that helps. Two popular choices among knife enthusiasts are 7Cr17MoV and CPM-S30V. For those who venture into demanding environments or require knives for robust tasks, M4 is a standout performer. 52100 low alloy steel is easier to sharpen and tougher than S30V steel. But S30V loses in front of LC200N when it comes to corrosion resistance and ease of sharpening. Production of H1 Steel for Knives. Moderate toughness compared to M4; Edge retention could be better; Applications and Real-World Performance Heavy-Duty and Outdoor Applications. Vivi wrote: ↑ wrote: ↑ 10Cr15CoMoV steel comparison 10Cr15CoMoV vs S30V. The D2 knife steel is durable and has decent edge retention. This is because of the complexity of a special manufacturing process involved in Cold Steel likes to point out that it may be even better in durability, strength, and edge retention. 14C28N is a good steel for tools like scalpels, but S30V is considered a premium steel. S30V is indeed much easier to acquire than CTS-XHP. On the other hand, despite being at the lower/cheaper end of the super steel family, the S30V showcases extraordinary hardness and wear resistance. S30V is as good or better than most knife people will ever need. I have a NIB of the CTS-XHP and would not wish to trade for the S30V. LC200N vs. But mainly, because Rex 45 is tougher than S30V, it can maintain a more acute edge which translates into better edge retention. However there are other steel properties which 1. S30V and S45VN are two prominent blade steels that often get compared. 12c27 steel has a Rockwell hardness of 58-59 HRC. So, let’s get started! About S35VN Steel CPM-S30V –Referred to as a true stainless steel, CPM S30V was developed by Dick Barber of Crucible Industries, with the help of Chris Reeve, and is known for excellent corrosion resistance. Therefore, if you invest in S30V knives, make sure to wipe them dry CPM CruWear vs S30V Steel Hardness. Its composition features a reduced vanadium content of 3%, coupled with the addition of 0. Interesting, I have had the same problems with S30V with chipping with light use. Sharpening ease. However, those seeking superior edge retention might opt for high-end steels like VG10 or S30V. SPY27 is hard steel but not extremely hard; therefore, sharpening is not a big challenge. , good toughness, good edge retention, etc) It's not super sharp, like ZDP or totally rust resistant, like H1, but fair's well in almost every catagory. i think the comparison to s30v is a S30V and CPM-20CV are two steels that are considered to be among the best and most well-rounded of all the steels out there. Crucible lists the transverse Charpy C-notch impact energy for S45VN as 11. 8Cr13MoV is a budget steel and S30V is a premium steel. S30V can be hardened to around 60-64 HRC through H1 Steel. Therefore, if you invest in S30V knives, make sure to wipe them dry after use, and they will remain rust-free for as long as you have them. R. Carbon C 0. D2 Steel Vs S30V Comparison Table. The result is a steel that retains all the extraordinary qualities of the original I guess my first question would be, why is H1 not being/not able to be produced anymore, yet an entirely new recipe steel can be? What CTS 204P, CPM CRUWEAR, CPM S30V, N690Co, M390, CPM MagnaCut, LC200N, CTS XHP, H1, 8Cr13MoV, GIN-1, CTS BD1 S45VN vs S30V Composition Are S45VN and S30V Knives The Same? S45VN and S30V knives are not the same. It is a relatively hard steel that can be heat treated to a hardness of up to 61 HRC. It’s on par with S30V or so. The hardness of a steel directly impacts its wear resistance and edge retention. 20CV vs S30V Steel. CRUWEAR outperforms S30V in wear resistance, One notable aspect of S30V steel is the use of the Crucible Particle Metallurgy (CPM) The toughness of the AUS 10 steel also ensures that the knives will not easily break or chip under pressure during sharpening and repeated cutting. However, they have differences that should be compared so you know which steel is better and why. Joined Jun 12, 2006 Messages 213. CPM S45VN is a martensitic stainless steel designed to offer improved CPM S30V steel vs S35VN steel? I have been debating sending in my 2005 Sebenza for a new blade with the S35VN steel. You should do a test and share it on your YouTube. SPY27 vs other steels Spy27 vs S30V vs S35VN The Basics: S30V. HAP40 vs S30V When it comes to choosing the perfect knife steel, enthusiasts are often met with the intriguing matchup of S30V versus VG10. S30V steel also offers better edge retention and wear resistance than 52100 steel due to high volume of carbides. Rento. This article will delve into the nitty-gritty of these two, providing comprehensive information, insightful analysis, and personal experiences with both materials. Not definitive tests, but great data How do you feel about H1 vs LC200N? CPM 15V, CTS 204P, CPM CRUWEAR, CPM S30V, N690Co, M390, CPM MagnaCut, LC200N, CTS XHP, H1, 8Cr13MoV, GIN-1, CTS BD1, VG-10, VG-10 Although not sold or supported in North America, also have G. BD1N vs S30V vs VG10 interesting result from cut test. Just like S35VN, S30V forms hard carbides that give it an all-around good performance in terms of edge retention, toughness, and corrosion resistance over Nitro V knife steel. I also have to break down those knives and clean corrosion off blades, liners, etc. AEB-L vs S30V. It’s very hard and exceptionally difficult to sharpen. Here are a few that are worth looking into. Let’s start with a disclaimer. The H1 steel produced for Spyderco is reported to begin with 7 mm stock and is cold rolled down to the final thickness required [8], to as thick as 3 mm for a Schempp chopper [9], or probably as An article about the highly corrosion resistant H1 steel. You have them in your Victorinox swiss army knives, Spiderco Salts in H1, and they're common in gas-station knives/mall-ninja On the other hand, S30V steel is a bit more fiddly regarding heat treatment, requiring specialized equipment and experienced professionals to handle the manufacturing process properly. It’s much better at retaining its sharp edge too. Wish H1 was included like others in the corrosion resistant 10 rating: LC200N and Vanax. 5 corrosion resistant rating like: M390/20CV/204P (favorite EDC steel for corrosion resistance and edge retention in a small 3” blade length folder). D2’s high carbon and chromium carbide content make it highly resistant to wear, Evolution of Steel Design Prior to S30V 154CM was designed for bearings, and was essentially a modification of 440C by reducing the chromium (Cr) by ~3% and adding 4% molybdenum (Mo). Nitro V beats S30V in ease of sharpness and may even beat S30V in sharpness if sharpened to perfection. S110V vs S30v steel comparison table Hardness. The downside is the increased brittleness that may accompany such hardness. CRUWEAR and S30V are popular steels used for knives. I have a previous article about the design of H1 and how it “works” which you can read here. Here’s how S30V and S90V stand up against other notable CPM steels. On a scale of 1 to 10, 15V knife steel has a toughness of 3, which is very low and comparable to other low toughness steels like S110V. Much, much Both LC200N steel and H1 steel are nitrogen steels but differ in properties, with H1 steel offering better toughness, corrosion resistance, and easy sharpening. Machinability: H1 steel is great for machinability; it has Molybdenum and Sulfur. At A GlanceCPM M4, a high-speed tool steel, excels in toughness and wear resistance, offering superior edge retention, but is less resistant to corrosion and. It is also very corrosion resistant and will stay sharp longer than other steels. Both 10Cr15CoMoV steel and CPM S30V have almost an identical level of hardness, their alloys are however very different. A recent Spyderco Byte has announced a replacement for H1 steel – H2. The factory grinding on the serrated edges apparantly "pre-work hardens" the edge giving it better retention than it's plain edge siblings. It’s like the jack of all trades for knife steel: It’s a well-balanced steel when it comes to the different properties it exhibits. D2 tool steel and S30V both excel in edge retention, but their performance is optimized for different uses. Sakai Sabi knives in H1 and their “mystery steel” which is LC200N even though not labeled on Nice job on the ranking. Plenty of YouTube “tests” trying to corrode LC200N and they can’t even get it to spot. It is worth mentioning that A2 tool steel is cheaper compared to S30V. SF Native Member Posts: 1431 Joined: Wed Aug 10, 2016 2:25 pm S30V is a great all-around steel. H1 steel is Precipitation-Hardened steel. I only got one knife in S45 but have not experienced a similar problem. The molybdenum was added so that the bearings could be operated at high temperature, but it was discovered that partially replacing Cr with Mo led to similar corrosion Due to the presence of Carbon in S30V, S35VN, etc instead of forming Nitrides, the Nitrogen takes on a different role within the steel, and augments other aspects of the steel Meanwhile with H1, due to it only having trace amounts of Carbon, the Nitrogen can form Nitrides. S30V was specifically designed to excel in wear resistance, with its composition balanced to promote the formation of hard vanadium carbides, which are more effective than chromium carbides in providing wear Background. Second, S90V is harder to sharpen than S30V not because of hardness, but because of its composition. S30V is still less expensive than S35VN. H1 vs LC200N corrosion . Edge Retention. Their alloy compositions are slightly different, with S30V containing more vanadium and S30V, a high-end stainless steel, is balanced. On the other hand, S30V is hard steel and delivers decent toughness. Hardness, indicative of the steel’s resistance to wear and deformation, greatly influences the edge retention. This allows the formation of a high percentage of Vanadium Carbides. SPY27 has less carbide than S45VN, S30V, and 345VN, while S110V has a high volume fraction of vanadium-rich and niobium-rich primary alloy carbides. S110V: S110V is another super steel with excellent edge retention and corrosion K390 vs S30V steel Hardness. Final Verdict Overall, both 440C and S30V steel have their advantages and disadvantages , with 440C being more affordable and easier to sharpen, while S30V is known for its superior edge D2 tool steel is typically more expensive than S30V steel due to its higher carbon content and higher chromium content. The S30V is widely regarded as premium steel, so it’s quite more expensive than the 14c28n steel. S30V was introduced in 2001 and S35VN in 2009, and both are currently in production by Crucible Industries LLC. Low springness, and I’m not sure if I can call this steel ‘tough’. S30V and CPM-20CV are two steels that are considered to be among the best and most well-rounded of all the steels out there. it's great for most people's edc needs as well. When enough Vanadium is in a steel, it bonds with some of the carbon content and forms a Vanadium carbide. However, S30V generally achieves slightly higher hardness than Cru-Wear. Common uses for spy27 and s30v steel. S30V is a premium stainless steel that boasts exceptional wear resistance and edge retention. FEEDBACK: The Good, The Bad, The Ugly! Hall of Fame Hall of Shame. As for edge retention, it performs pretty well. S30V and CPM-S30V are the same steel; S30V S45VN steel has slightly better toughness compared to S30V steel. D2 and S30V are two popular blade steels often put head to head. Just Cost. S30V was released at the end of 2001 as a high-end steel. In partnership with Crucible Industries, a steel producer based in New York, Chris Reeve developed the S35VN and S30V steels using a specialized technique known as Crucible Particle Metal (CPM) technology. To begin analyzing S30V vs S35VN for hunting knife and chef’s knife applications, both S35VN and S30V steels are modern, high-performance steels developed by Crucible Steel utilizing their Crucible Particle Metallurgy (CPM) process. Finally, don't worry too much about what knife has what steel. While they S30V vs S90V steel comparison table Hardness. Search. It’s hard to go wrong with 1. vs. 420HC knives will withstand high-impact applications compared to 420HC Knives. The recommended hardness range for 14C28N steel is 55-62 HRC (Rockwell Hardness C scale). Conclusion. S30V steel finds its origins in the high-end market. If you're new to knives, you'll be in great shape with that steel from a major maker. While the AUS 10a can be quite tough, the CTS BD1 may be a bit tougher. Exploring S30V and CPM154 Steel S30V Steel: An Overview. H1 is hard to chip, but easy to bend and it doesn’t get back. I find the S35 easier to sharpen to a razor edge, edge retention is about the same. The S30V is notably better at retaining its sharp edge, so Interesting, I have had the same problems with S30V with chipping with light use. Both CTS XHP and S30V steel are capable of achieving high hardness levels up to around 64 HRC. S30V steel is better than CTS BD1N steel in edge retention and toughness. S30V steel is great for making blades that will be used for everyday tasks such as slicing and cutting. Search Advanced search. Short Answer: Comparing S30V to CPM-20CV S30V is a more well-rounded steel that is good Exploring S30V and CPM154 Steel S30V Steel: An Overview. Sales of steel to the knife industry took off much more for Crucible once S30V was introduced in 2001, giving the knife industry a steel they seemed to be much more interested in. I would pick s30v or 154cm over AUS8 though, and I am not all that crazy about s30v anyway. On the other hand, S30V steel is a bit more fiddly regarding heat treatment, requiring specialized equipment and experienced professionals to handle the manufacturing process properly. S30V is a premium stainless steel and offers better edge retention and corrosion resistance than 1095 steel. Recent CPM CRUWEAR vs S30V – Complete Comparison Hardness. PH steel does not require heat treatment to become hard, and its 1% nitrogen composition prevents rusting. Two popular premium steels that have made their name on the market are S30V and Magnacut. Now that we have looked at the short answer, we can look closer at each steel, what elements they are made of, how they compare in-depth, and the best knives in each steel. CPM CRUWEAR has a Rockwell hardness (HRC) of 63-65, ensuring impressive wear resistance and edge retention. S30V has a Rockwell hardness (HRC) of 59-61, renowned for a good balance between edge retention and toughness. CRK is switching over to S35V over the next 12 months - and it is reported that it might offer 15-20% more toughness that S30V - but I probably wouldn't notice the difference with my usage. Having tested a Stretch and endura in ZDP189, a military and a paramilitary in S30V, an endura in VG-10 and a Gayle bradley in CPM-M4, I get confusing results. VG10 vs S30v – Usability. LC200N stainless steel achieves excellent corrosion resistance through 15% chromium and 0. 0%. Within this realm, two materials stand out as both special and widely misunderstood: D2 and S30V steel. Either way, you can’t go wrong with these two cutting-edge steels. The datasheet for S110V shows it can reach 64 HRC when properly heat treated in contrast, the datasheet for S30V indicates a maximum hardness of 62 HRC. But in other ways, these 2 steels are very different. S30V stainless steel is premium steel, blue steel Chef knife Chef Knives CPM 3V CPM 4V CPM 154 CROMOVA Cronidur 30 D2 steel Damascus drop point Elmax FRN G10 grivory H1 H2 LC200N M390 MagnaCut MC66 Micarta n690 pocket knife Rex 45 rex 121 s30v S35VN S45VN S90V SG2 SUS410 Tanto VG 10 Steel D2 vs S35VN composition D2 Knife Characteristics. As a result, the steel can hold a cutting edge similar H1 steel is Japanese-origin precipitation-hardened steel that offers excellent corrosion resistance. However, VG10 tends to be slightly easier to sharpen due to its lower vanadium content. HAP40 vs S30V Production of H1 Steel for Knives. Due to its softer composition, 12c27 steel does not retain its edge as well as s30v steel. LC200N vs S30V Steel Comparison Table Corrosion Resistance. It's pretty good stuff, though as Cliff said I am pretty sure my Spyderco in s30v had some issues before multiple sharpenings. You must be logged in to post a comment. It's very well rounded (good rust res. Here is the short answer: S30V is better steel than 420HC. The higher hardness potential of S110V is enabled by its higher alloy To begin analyzing S30V vs S35VN for hunting knife and chef’s knife applications, both S35VN and S30V steels are modern, high-performance steels developed by Crucible Steel utilizing their Crucible Particle Metallurgy (CPM) process. It is also known as CPM S30V steel, emphasizing the Crucible Industries’ CPM process. I like CRK S30V - I have an Umnumzaan and Sebenza and the steel holds up well for what I use my knives for. Whether you are a chef, a survivalist, or just someone who appreciates a quality blade, understanding the distinctions between these two popular steels can significantly influence your decision-making process. Just to start off I think if you're primarily seeking edge retention in a knife, Victorinox steel also called 1. Whichever steel your next knife uses will see you good for most tasks you come up against! With that said, let’s start by looking at how each metal performs as part of day-to-day use! Durability 8Cr13MoV and S30V are pretty much on the opposite ends of the steel spectrum. 20CV However, S30V will be harder to sharpen and more expensive compared to 14C28N. 73 posts Previous; 1; 2; 3; 4 The ease of sharpness in steel goes hand in hand with hardness. H2, CPM 20CV, CPM 15V, CTS 204P, CPM CRUWEAR, CPM S30V, N690Co, M390, CPM MagnaCut, LC200N, CTS XHP, H1, 8Cr13MoV, GIN-1, CTS BD1, VG-10, VG-10/Damascus, 440C, MBS-26. I have alot of serrated h1 and alot of plain edge lc200n. Although their differences are not that substantial, the knives differ in properties like edge retention, corrosion resistance, and ease of sharpening. S30V has more carbon and Vanadium in its alloy. . Toughness: The h1 Knife steel is a vital aspect to consider when selecting a blade. H1 was first used in American production knives by Benchmade around 2002-2003 and shortly after by Spyderco [7]. 0% compared to S30V steel’s 4. The corrosion resistance of VG10 and CPM S30V steels is at par with the likes of 440C steel and SG2 steel but slightly lower than that of M390 Steel, N690 steel, and BD1N steel. In this article, we will explore the composition and characteristics of each steel and compare them to determine which one may be the better choice for your specific needs. Post by alucardje » Fri May 25, 2012 12:02 pm. 10V steel is harder than S30V and provides better wear resistance, toughness, and edge retention. LC200N/H1 > S45VN ~ 20CV/M390 >> S90V ~ S30V edge retention: S90V >> 20CV/M390 ~ S45VN ~ S30V > LC200N. S30V steel exhibits significantly superior edge retention and wear resistance compared to Nitro-V steel, with S30V offering nearly twice edge retention. CPM 154 vs S30V. Post by BornIn1500 » Tue May 14, (H1), Salt 2 SE (LC200N), and also Wayne Goddard PE (4V) Top. Due to the use of vanadium carbides, CPM S30V has a very refined grain which helps improve the sharpness and toughness of knives using this steel. In conclusion, 20CV steel is better than S30V in aspects of edge retention, blue steel Chef knife Chef Knives CPM 3V CPM 4V CPM 154 CROMOVA Cronidur 30 D2 steel Damascus drop point Elmax FRN G10 grivory H1 H2 LC200N M390 MagnaCut MC66 Micarta n690 pocket knife Rex 45 rex 121 s30v S35VN S45VN S90V Blade steel is a key consideration when choosing a knife. Carrying the sheepsfoot caribbean right now. This makes it harder to steel and more resistant to wear and tear. This minor improvement in toughness in S45VN can be attributed to its modified compositin and the use of niobium, which helps refine the carbide structure and improve toughness. Now we can take a closer look at each steel, when you would want one steel over the other, and what the best tasks are for each steel. K390 and S30V can go longer between sharpenings, sure. It scores average for ease of I can quickly see that Elmax, CTS-XHP, CPM-S30V, CPM-S35VN, and CPM-4V are the steels that fit the criteria, while the other steels with high edge retention filter out, because they have low performance in toughness, corrosion H1 steel, what's the catch? - truly 100% resistant to staining. So given a choice, I'd go with CV20 every time. BD1N nitrogen-based alloy, blue steel Chef knife Chef Knives CPM 3V CPM 4V CPM 154 CROMOVA Cronidur 30 D2 steel Damascus drop point Elmax FRN G10 grivory H1 H2 LC200N M390 MagnaCut MC66 Micarta n690 pocket knife Rex 45 rex 121 s30v S35VN S45VN S90V SG2 I have a fair bit of experience with both S30V and CV20/M390, and IMO there is no contest; I prefer CV20. It has its challenges and especially if you are not seasoned in sharpening. I think there could be some discussion on a few, like ZDP vs S30V on edge retention, ZDP vs 440C on corrosion resistance, and also O1 on corrosion. Related: How good is S90V steel for knives? CTS BD1 vs VG10. Here is the short answer: There is no difference between S30V and CPM-S30V. It’s celebrated for its superb edge retention and high corrosion resistance. 9Cr18MoV vs S30V. S30V is expensive steel that is known for great edge retention, corrosion resistance and also has a high hardness rating. Sam Carver blue steel Chef knife Chef Knives CPM 3V CPM 4V CPM 154 CROMOVA Cronidur 30 D2 steel Damascus drop point Elmax FRN G10 grivory H1 H2 LC200N M390 MagnaCut MC66 Micarta n690 pocket knife Rex 45 Knives with S30V and S35VN blades have proven popular in the medium and premium-priced knife markets. K390 steel vs S30V. If rust resistance is important to you, could go with LC200N, which is pretty close to H1 in that regard and pretty decent (around S30V according to tests I CPM 15V Steel Toughness. Conclusion on 20CV vs S30V. 10Cr15CoMoV steel comparison 10Cr15CoMoV vs S30V. 7% – 14. S30V. After we went through the details about the S30V Steel, we finally arrived at our famous question, Is S30V good knife steel, I guess by now the answer is obvious “YES”, the steel offers high hardness, high wear resistance, high corrosion resistance, and a decent toughness, it’s considered a high-end Steel, and many users consider as a “SUPER STEEL”, And honestly 420HC and S30V are steels used by some of the biggest knife brands in the US. I hate that I dont have any serrated lc200n because I would gladly do a torture test to destruction of the two. S30V Steel Qualities. Sharpening them is very fast, and I don't have to worry about rust at all. The high amount of vanadium carbide gives 10V better performance in edge retention and would still cut even when a bit blunt as the vanadium carbide would grab on the material being cut. Let’s look at which steel is better and why. It also improves steel resistance to wear, abrasion and corrosion. The H1 steel produced for Spyderco is reported to begin with 7 mm stock and is cold rolled down to the final thickness required [8], to as thick as 3 mm for a Schempp chopper [9], or probably as Discuss Spyderco's products and history. Criteria: CTS BD1: VG10: Edge retention: 7/10: 5/10: CPM CruWear vs S30V Steel Hardness. Discuss Spyderco's products and history. It seems like S35VN was introduced as an improvement to s30V, as you find with CRK folders and other brands. It’s still considered a premium steel, and one of the best all-around steels you’ll be able to get for a knife. When it comes to choosing a steel for a knife, there are many options to consider. In HRC, a lower number is indicative of a harder steel. VG10 is a more newbie friendly steel offering good performance while still being easy to S30V vs M390 – Complete Comparison Hardness. VG-10 steel is a premium Japanese steel that offers better properties like hardness, edge retention, and corrosion resistance. When comparing VG10 vs S30v steel, both are good quality metals for an everyday carry knife. H1. This is the only blade steel on the market that is really, truly, 100% corrosion-proof. Jul 7, The BD1 is the cheapest and unless one of the other ones is greatly superior I would lean toward that. 73 posts Previous; 1; 2; 3; 4 H1 is a great steel, hit it with a butchers steel in between sharpens and never have to worry about poor edge retention GB1 is my hunting knife, Can't beat M4 for the tuff stuff. The “S” in S30V stands for stainless because S30V is a stainless steel. CPM 154 is on par with S30V, as it is the powder steel version of 154CM, but anyone who says 154CM is 'better' than S30V is doing so because of sentimental value of 154CM on a certain knife, rather than an objective perspective. As always, steel with high hardness makes blades with good edge retention, which is true with D2 tool steel. I have a number of S30V blades and a ZT 0550 in S35VN. In fact, it’s an all-around steel that somehow is the opposite of H1. When deciding between d2 tool steel vs s30v steel for your next knife purchase, consider your intended purpose and environment – whether you plan to use your knife indoors or outdoors, whether you need more edge S30V is a high end blade steel, 303 Stainless is too soft a steel for blades and is what a balisong maker might use for handles. If it is an Endura 4 it comes in VG-10, ZDP-189, H1, and the aforementioned VG-10 Damascus. LC200N Steel vs S30V. S30V’s heat treatment is better suited for creating a more uniform hardness, which is useful in making knives that handle extreme wear and tear. This difference in carbide content and distribution plays a crucial role in toughness. S30V can be hardened to around 60-64 HRC through Deep Dive into S30V Steel. LC200N equals H1 for corrosion resistance. Chromium Cr 12. On the other hand, ZDP189 shines in edge retention and corrosion resistance because it contains high Chromium levels. Rex45 is a better steel relative to S30V. H1 is known for being a very high corrosion resistance steel used primarily in Spyderco’s Salt line of knives. What is the purpose of S45VN, cf S30V? S45VN’s card cut is around 520 compared to S30V which is in the 600 range, according to a Doc Thomas graphic. Plus back when S30V was realized to be the ideal "everyday" supersteel, companies like Spyderco and others bought large amounts in order to offer such an amazing steel at reasonable prices. Crucible datasheets indicate that the aim hardness for S90V steel is typically in the range of 56-59 HRC, while the aim hardness for S30V steel is 58-61 HRC. 5 zdp/CF; Chapparel FRN cts xhp; Southard 204p; Kapara s30v; Ikuchi s30v; Spydiechef lc200n, Waterway Lc200n; Manix 2 LW 20cv Past Spyderco: Endura zdp; Manix 2 LW s110v; Paramilitary 2 s30v. Myodo: H1 Takefu: VG-10 Zapp: LC200N. It was designed to offer a balanced combination of corrosion resistance, hardness, edge retention, and toughness. It was designed in the US and is typically used for the high-end premium pocket H1 Steel vs S30V. S30v steel has a Rockwell hardness of 60-61 HRC. CPM 10V vs S30V. Now sure, don't try to beat on your Mamet steel because it WILL snap. The S30V is notably better at retaining its sharp edge, so H1 is really optimized to be extremely rust resistant (I want to say essentially rust proof) and sacrifices in other areas. Hello guys, I have a question. This steel is durable enough to withstand rigorous use without chipping or breaking. As we’ve suggested, S30V is great at resistance to getting old and broken down. CTS BD1 has better edge retention, slightly lower toughness, and slightly lower corrosion resistance, and requires insignificantly more dedication to sharpening compared to S30V. It's very different than most other knife steels for several reasons, including that the steel is not heat treated by the knife manufacturer. CPM S30V steel offers better toughness than K390 knife steel. VG10. h1 This is the only blade steel on the market that is really, truly, 100% corrosion-proof. You're going to love lc200n its h1 but with cutting performance similar to s30v S30v steel is a premium stainless steel offering better corrosion resistance than 52100, which does not contain enough chromium to make it stainless steel. These range from charts listing the composition of various steel alloys to articles and videos that focus on the cutting performance and other attributes of particular knives, CPM-S90V, CPM-S110V, CPM-S30V, CPM-S35VN, CPM-154, 154CM. This steel has a smooth texture which gives it a more refined, modern look. S30V steel, on the other hand, is more Like the LC200N, the H1 is also a nitrogen-based steel grade like the LC200N so it’s quite different. I re-profiled Rex45 without much On the other hand, S35VN is a modification of the popular S30V knife steel, designed to improve toughness and machinability. S30V’s superior chromium content offers better corrosion resistance than AEB-L. Cost. So, let’s get started! About S35VN Steel D2 tool steel is typically more expensive than S30V steel due to its higher carbon content and higher chromium content. The main difference between S30V and S35VN steel is their toughness. It even outperforms the higher S90V in those aspects. S30V . I’m much more familiar with those in the 9-9. Top. Next . Hardness is crucial in knife steel as it directly influences edge retention and wear resistance. 4110 excels at and why it's my amateur opinion it is being given too much undeserved dislike in the knife community. It is usually heat treated to a hardness of around 58-60 HRC. The main difference is that S45VN is an improvement of S30V steel. Blade steel makes a whole lot less of a difference than so many people will have you You're looking at about 525 for S35VN vs. Leave a Comment Cancel Reply. If you’re searching s30v vs 154cm you want to know which one is S30V vs 154CM: Best Steel Choice for Your Pocket Knife. H1 vs. With diamonds it sharpens as easily as S30V. S110V steel has the potential for significantly higher hardness than S30V steel. CPM-440V was rebranded to CPM-S60V some time around the year 2000 [8], and CPM-420V was renamed to CPM-S90V. The edge retention of D2 is better than that of 154CM, grade 440C and it is similar to that of CPM 3V steel but significantly worse than that of S35VN, S30V, and M390 steels. AUS-10 vs other steel AUS-10 vs VG-10 Steel. SPY27 and S30V have “good” or “above average” corrosion resistance but cannot match 420. 14c28n vs S30v Steel. I'm a huge autistic nerd and it doesn't matter that much for the most part. See more H1 steel knives LC 200N. The D2 knife steel is averagely tough and, therefore, can not be used for highly challenging applications like prying. Short Answer: S30V See more S30V steel knives S90V. I read somewhere that H1 plain edges apparantly start out with questionable edge retention but supposedly get better at it over time with the "steel" becoming increasingly harder after use. You will witness H1 steel performing better with a serrated edge and LC200N performing better with a plain edge. Let’s break down all the key differences between these two steels to help you make an informed decision for your next pick. S30V is a very well-rounded premium steel. LC200N and S30V are stainless steel, however, LC200N has superior corrosion resistance compared to S30V due to its composition. 5% nitrogen, with very little carbon to form chromium carbides. ZDP-189 is a harder steel than CPM-S30V and is capable of holding an edge for a longer period of time. This Vanadium content gives it higher hardness and wear resistance while enhancing its edge retention ability due to the formation of hard Vanadium Carbides. In this article, we will be contrasting S30V and S45VN based on their composition, This is typically exemplified by blade edge retention. However, HAP40 steel performs better in toughness, it is easier to sharpen and gains a sharp edge faster. This method ensures that the carbides, the hard particles that keep the blade sharp, are distributed evenly throughout the steel, resulting in a more No steel is 'better' until you define a large enough picture of how and what the knife will be cutting and what sort of geometry the edge will have. S35VN steel is considered to be tougher and is, therefore, better suited for larger knives such as hunting, tactical, and survival knives. There are 7th tier steels. LC200N edge retention . Distinct Qualities of S30V Steel. S30V is a premium steel, so it’s not quite fair to compare it directly with the more affordable (but still upper-midrange) CTS BD1. The S30V and 420 were also austenitized at 1950°F. S30V vs CPM154 – Complete Comparison Hardness. Yet, S30V cannot beat H1 steel in The 60 and 30 in S60V and S30V stands for vanadium. S30V is also a martensitic stainless steel created for specific use in cutlery. This means that steels with high hardness offer low toughness, which is true with 15V. The Rex45 NC costs the same as the one in S30V. S30V is considered, by some, to be the best steel on the market. S30V: You will see S30V beating LC200N steel in edge retention. Lucabrasi Niolox Steel Composition. S30V steel, also known as CPM S30V, is a premium grade stainless steel designed by Crucible Industries with the input of renowned knifemaker Chris Reeve. However, in practical knife applications, K390 and S30V are often heat-treated to more modest hardness levels in the 58-62 HRC You can use S30V steel knives outdoors or in the kitchen, cutting acidic foods without fear of the blade picking up rust. 6. Key Takeaways. 115Italian. When we say about the exceptional corrosion resistance feature steel knife, it reminds us of H1 Steel, which is equivalent to budget steel. It usually handle a pretty wide range of tasks given to it. Knife Steel Guide Hardest Knife Steel • 5 Best Knife Steels • Best Budget Knife Steel • Carbon vs Stainless Steel • Worst Knife Steel Knife Steel CPM-20CV • S30V • S35VN • S45VN • S90V • S110V • 420HC • 420J2 • 440C H1: Myodo Metals: 57-58: Exceptional corrosion resistance: 0. Made by US based Crucible, CPM S30V (often simply referred to as S30V) steel has excellent edge retention and resists rust effortlessly. 1095 steel vs S30V. It keeps an edge for a long time, so you do not have to sharpen them after every use. After we went through the details about the S30V Steel, we finally arrived at our famous question, Is S30V good knife steel, I guess by now the answer is obvious “YES”, the steel offers high hardness, high wear resistance, high corrosion resistance, and a decent toughness, it’s considered a high-end Steel, and many users consider as a “SUPER STEEL”, And honestly 14c28n vs S30v Steel. Edge Retention: D2 vs. S30V is a premium steel with an all-around performance, but it cannot beat H2 in corrosion resistance, toughness, and ease of sharpening. Can VG10 or S30V steel be sharpened easily? Both VG10 and S30V steel can be sharpened with relative ease. I think the burnt orange is nicer than black G10. 0 ft-lbs, while for S30V, it is 10. Something like H1 steel has a high chromium content and thus is regarded as one of the best mid-grade corrosion-resistant steels. I could not tell the difference between the two heat treatments in this case, however. On the other hand, S30v steel is a stainless steel alloy that is highly resistant to corrosion, making it ideal for those who don’t want to worry about rust and need a durable blade. This family of steel includes varieties such as S30V, S35VN, S45VN, M4, 20CV, 3V, and S90V, just to name a few. - and supposedly DOESN'T get brittle at higher HRCs, in theory placing it above exotic supersteels like ZDP LC200N equals H1 for corrosion resistance. But they take a little longer to sharpen. I'm sure more expensive than 440c, though. The s30v is much harder, so it cuts better even against stronger materials. The Knife Seen Here: Chris Reeve Sebenza 31. i think it will have the most effect on tool steel usage and outdoor knives. 8Cr13MoV vs VG10 Steel. CPM 154 steel equivalent is Swedish Damasteel produced RWL 34 stainless steel. BG42 vs S30V. increased toughness combined with high corrosion resistance is about the perfect recipe for an outdoor knife. When it comes to sharpness, Nitro V is known for its excellent edge retention and is able to maintain an edge for a longer period of time. S60V has roughly 6% vanadium by weight and S30V has about 4% (was 3%, hence the 3, but got reformulated a Popular knife models like Spyderco’s Salt series employ H1 steel due to its durability and low maintenance requirements. qosqe dgm rseo ojqe vrtfof urk kyixqmjl ild qtoll mxqukr